RESPONSE TO REVIEWER COMMENTS Edmund Storms
نویسندگان
چکیده
I want to thank the reviewers (IE #108) for taking the time to make interesting and sometimes useful comments on my paper, “Cold Fusion from a Chemist’s Point of View.” This is the first and hopefully not the last time a proposed explanation of LENR has been reviewed publicly in such detail. The process is effective in revealing not only flaws but also how the ideas can be better explained to avoid misunderstanding. I will comment on each review in the order they appeared in IE #108.
منابع مشابه
Cold Fusion from a Chemist’s Point of View Edmund Storms Comments on Storms’ Ideas About the Location and Mechanism for LENR
Very small cracks are proposed as the location of the LENR process in a material. A resonance process is proposed to occur in these structures, resulting in fusion, while energy is emitted as coherent photons having a characteristic energy. The nuclear product depends on which isotope of hydrogen is present. Reasons are given why a crack structure is required to explain LENR.
متن کاملارزیابی میزان دقت داوران یکی از مجلات علمی پژوهشی فارسی زبان در تشخیص اصلاحات مورد نیاز یک مقاله علمی ارسالی؛ سال 1389
Background and Objectives: Final corrections on a manuscript sent for publication in a scientific journal are suggested by reviewers. So this qualifies the paper with the least errors for publication. The present study aimed to assess the Persian language peer reviewers' comments on a manuscript sent to an Iranian Scientific Journal (journal of Rafsanjan university of medical sciences), 2010....
متن کاملThe role of motor network reorganization during rehabilitation
rehabilitation”. Reviewer: Samit Chakrabarty, University of Leeds, UK. Comments to the author: This article makes certain assumptions that are based on selective reading of the literature and has a feeling of being highly speculative. 2 major assumptions that I disagree with; a. motor network suggests only cortical is involved, unless one states it to be the cortical motor networks and b. role ...
متن کاملAuthor ' s response to reviews Title : Socio - economic
Comments in Bullet 1 The reviewer indicated that it would be more interesting if authors could present results on the outcome of deliveries conducted by TBAs and those conducted in hospitals. The reviewer assumed that MICS has this information as well. Response to comments Bullet 1 Data on outcome of deliveries was not collected in the Iraq MICS. Comments in Bullet 2 The reviewer suggested that...
متن کامل